Meal replacement diet plan: 1, 2 or 3 shakes a day?
A meal replacement diet plan swaps one, two or all of your daily meals for products made to UK rules. The law links two a day plus one meal you cook to weight loss, and one a day to keeping weight off after weight loss. Replacing every meal is a short plan to check with your GP first.
Key points
- The UK authorised claims say "Substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss" and "Substituting one of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with a meal replacement contributes to the maintenance of weight after weight loss".1
- Each meal replacement must give 200-250 kcal and at least 30% of the reference values for vitamins and minerals.1
- The law also says other foods should be a necessary part of the diet when you use one or two a day.1
- Replacing every meal is total diet replacement: not for more than 8 weeks without a healthcare professional's advice.3
What is a meal replacement diet plan?
A meal replacement diet plan is a calorie-controlled plan where set meals are swapped for products that meet UK meal replacement rules. The products must provide 200-250 kcal per meal, along with protein, vitamins and minerals in set amounts.1
The number of meals you replace shapes the plan. Here are the three patterns:
- One a day
- One meal replaced, two ordinary meals. Usually for keeping weight off after weight loss.
- Two a day
- Two meals replaced, one meal you cook. This is the pattern the UK authorised claim links to weight loss.
- All meals
- Every meal replaced. A short plan, with a GP's advice.
Two a day is the pattern on our Everyday and Active Plans.5 You get structure for most of your meals while still sitting down to one real meal. The rules say "other foodstuffs should be a necessary part of such diet".1
Browse our meal replacement shakes for the full range, our full shakes guide for detailed advice, and 30 and 42 meal packs for the lower price per meal at £1.67.
If you're starting with one or two a day, here are four shakes that show how it works: two milk-made classics and two made for water, each in its own single-meal sachet.
Vanilla (212 kcal, 20.7g protein, rated 4.6 from 355 reviews) and Strawberry (210 kcal, 19.6g protein, rated 4.8 from 547 reviews) are made with 250ml skimmed milk. Caramel Biscuit (201 kcal, 18g protein, rated 4.6 from 38 reviews) and Lemon Cheesecake (201 kcal, 19g protein, rated 4.8 from 17 reviews) are made with 250ml cold water.
Each is one of 11 flavours in stock. £1.99 each, or £1.67 a meal in 30 and 42 meal packs (prices and nutrition checked 18 November 2026).6
Here's what customers say about these flavours:
“The strawberry shake and chicken soup are my two favourites, easy to use for work when busy, both taste nice”
“Love this shake, my new favourite when I can't get chocolate”
“Very tasty smooth and pleasant”
Reviews independently collected by Reviews.io. See all reviews
How many meal replacement shakes a day?
Two a day for weight loss, one a day to keep weight off after weight loss, all meals only short term with a GP check first.
The table below shows what each pattern looks like, what it is for, and which of our plans uses it.
| Pattern | What a day looks like | kcal a day | What it's for | Our plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One a day | One meal replacement, two ordinary meals | No set figure | Keeping weight off after weight loss | Maintenance Plan (tapers from two to one)5 |
| Two a day + a meal | Two meal replacements, one meal you cook, 200 kcal snacks | 1,000 | Weight loss with one normal meal | Everyday Plan5 |
| Two a day + a bigger meal + exercise | Two meal replacements, one bigger meal you cook, a 200 kcal snack | 1,200 | Weight loss with training | Active Plan5 |
| All meals on two days a week | Four meal replacements on fasting days, normal healthy eating on five days | About 800 on fasting days | Weight loss with normal eating most days | 5:2 Plan5 |
| All meals every day | Four meal replacements, 150ml skimmed milk for tea or coffee, 2 litres of fluid | 800 | Short structured plan, check with your GP first | Total Plan (the 800 kcal plan)5 |
The Everyday Plan starts with two meal replacements a day, then steps down to one a day on the Maintenance Plan. The 5:2 Plan replaces all meals on only two days a week, with normal healthy eating on the other five. You can compare our diet plans to see which suits your day.
Why choose Shake That Weight
Whichever pattern you pick from the table, here is why people choose Shake That Weight to follow it.
- Every shake meets the UK meal-replacement criteria when made as directed, with 250ml skimmed milk or water depending on the flavour.
- 11 flavours in stock, each in a single-meal sachet, mixed and matched in one box.
- Rated 4.5 out of 5 from 20,548 independently collected reviews.
- Trusted by 500,000+ customers since 2012, a regulated UK food company.
- Diet plans designed by a registered dietitian.
- £1.67 a meal in 30 or 42 packs, free standard delivery over £65 and next working day Express if ordered before 2:30pm.
One shake a day: what does it do?
One shake a day helps keep weight off after weight loss. The UK authorised claim wording is "Substituting one of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with a meal replacement contributes to the maintenance of weight after weight loss".1
You replace one main meal, usually breakfast or lunch. The rest of the day is normal balanced eating. There is no set kcal figure for this pattern, though our 1500 calorie meal plan shows one way to plan a day of balanced eating.
This is how the Maintenance Plan works. It starts at two meal replacements a day and tapers to one over stages of at least three to four weeks.5 See our guide to raising calories after a diet.
The other meals still matter because other foodstuffs should be a necessary part of the diet when you use meal replacements.1 Meal replacements work only as part of an energy-restricted diet. You need enough to drink each day too.1
Two shakes and one meal a day: the classic plan
Two shakes and one meal a day is the pattern the UK authorised claim links to weight loss. The exact wording is "Substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss".1
This is the Everyday Plan. A typical day looks like this:
| Meal | What you have | kcal |
|---|---|---|
| Breakfast | Meal replacement shake or soup | Around 200 kcal |
| Lunch | Meal replacement shake or soup | Around 200 kcal |
| Dinner | A meal you cook, about 400 kcal | Around 400 kcal |
| Snacks | 200 kcal of snacks | 200 kcal |
| Plus | 150ml skimmed milk for tea or coffee throughout the day |
The Everyday Plan gives you 1,000 kcal a day. You follow it for 8 weeks.5 You can use one of our meal replacement soups at breakfast or lunch, and our low calorie soup guide has home-made recipes for your cooked meal or snacks.
The Active Plan is the same structure with a bigger meal you cook. It is built to pair with 150 minutes of moderate exercise a week, or 75 minutes of vigorous exercise, and gives you 1,200 kcal a day.5 Our guide has three 1,200 calorie sample days.
A two-a-day plan is easy to keep up with sachets. One sachet is one meal, so breakfast and lunch are sorted with nothing to measure.
- One sachet is one meal: no scoops or weighing.
- Water-range flavours need only cold water: lunch at work or on the go is easy.
- Sealed sachets fit in a bag: a meal is always to hand.
- Mix flavours across a box: the Shake Selection 30 (9 Vanilla, 9 Banana, 6 Chocolate Mint, 6 Cherry Bakewell) is £1.67 a meal.
An Oxford review of 23 trials with 7,884 adults found that plans that include meal replacements led to more weight loss at one year than comparison diets, as group averages.4 Individual results vary. The review left out total diet replacement and diets under 800 kcal.
The reviewers concluded meal replacements are "a valid option".4 You can read more about what the evidence says.
Good to know
Weigh your cooked meal until your eye is trained. It is easy to creep over 400 kcal without noticing.
See the Everyday Plan or the Active Plan for full details.
Every plan below was designed by a registered dietitian, and you pick the one that fits your day.
Want to keep one normal meal?
The Everyday Plan is two meal replacements plus a meal you cook, at 1,000 kcal a day.
The Everyday PlanWant the fastest structure?
The Total Plan gives you four meal replacements a day at 800 kcal. Check with your GP before starting.
The 800 kcal planTraining as well?
The Active Plan pairs two meal replacements with a bigger meal and 150 minutes of moderate exercise a week, at 1,200 kcal a day.
The Active PlanCan you have 3 meal replacement shakes a day?
Three shakes and nothing else is not a plan we suggest.
Three milk-made shakes come to about 630 kcal (calculated from 210-212 kcal per shake made with 250ml skimmed milk).6 That is very-low-calorie territory. NICE says under 800 kcal a day should only be within a specialist service.2
There are two better routes. If you want two shakes a day, add a meal you cook and follow the Everyday Plan at 1,000 kcal. If you want a structured all-meals plan, follow the 800 kcal plan with four meal replacements, not three, after the checks in the box below.
Do not use a third shake as the Everyday Plan snack. One shake made up is 201-212 kcal,6 which is more than the whole 200 kcal snack allowance.
A single shake is one meal's worth. Only meal replacements made to the UK standard can carry the weight-loss claim. We don't recommend replacing meals with protein shakes, which are fine as a snack.
If you are interested in protein in a meal replacement, that guide explains why the protein in each meal matters.
Replacing every meal: the 800 kcal plan
Replacing every meal is total diet replacement. On the Total Plan you have four meal replacements, 150ml skimmed milk for tea or coffee, 2 litres of fluid, and you check with your GP first.5
The law says total diet replacement should not be used for more than 8 weeks, or repeatedly for shorter periods, without a healthcare professional's advice.3
NICE says 800-1,200 kcal diets should only be considered as part of a multicomponent strategy with long-term support within a specialist service. Under 800 kcal a day should only be within a specialist service. NICE adds that a very low-calorie diet is not a long-term strategy, and risks include weight cycling and regain.2
The NHS uses 800-900 kcal total diet replacement soups and shakes for 12 weeks for some adults with type 2 diabetes, via the GP. That is the NHS Path to Remission Programme. STW is not part of it.7
Check first
Talk to your GP before starting the Everyday Plan (1,000 kcal), the Active Plan (1,200 kcal) or the 800 kcal plan if you:
- are pregnant or breastfeeding
- are under 18
- have a history of eating disorders
- have type 1 diabetes, or diabetes on insulin or sulfonylureas
- take other medication that might need adjusting
- have a BMI under 25 for the 800 kcal plan
See the 800 kcal plan or read about a 7-day 800 calorie plan.
How to choose your plan
If you want one normal meal a day and a clear structure for the rest, start with the Everyday Plan. Two shakes plus a meal you cook is the pattern the UK law ties to weight loss in a meal replacement plan, and you can stick with it for 8 weeks.
- How much structure do you want? Two shakes and a meal gives you structure for most meals. All meals replaced is the tightest structure, but it is short term and needs a GP check first.
- Do you cook for a family? If you do, two shakes and a meal means you still sit down to one proper meal with them.
- How active are you? If you are training, the Active Plan gives you a bigger meal at 1,200 kcal a day. If you are on the 800 kcal plan, stick to light exercise only.5
- Any health conditions? Check with your GP before starting if you have diabetes, are on medication, or have any other health condition.
- What happens afterwards? After the Total Plan or the Everyday Plan, you step down to the Maintenance Plan. That tapers from two meal replacements a day to one.
If you want normal eating five days a week, the 5:2 Plan uses four meal replacements on two fasting days and normal healthy eating on the other five. Read more about who shakes suit as not everyone should use them.
Are meal replacements good for losing weight?
Yes, as part of an energy-restricted diet. The UK authorised claim says substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss.1
A review of 23 trials found that plans that include meal replacements led to more weight loss at one year than comparison diets, as group averages. Individual results vary.4 The reviewers concluded meal replacements are "a valid option".
Which meal should I replace?
Any main meal. A sachet fits in a bag, so lunch at work is easy. Breakfast and lunch are quick to make and you do not have to think about what to have.
Keep the meal you share with family or friends. That is usually dinner. On the Everyday Plan the meal you keep is the one you cook, at about 400 kcal.5
Can I mix meal replacement shakes with water?
Yes, if you choose a flavour made for water. We make five flavours for water: Tropical, Cherry Bakewell, Chocolate Hazelnut, Lemon Cheesecake and Caramel Biscuit. Vanilla and Strawberry are made with 250ml skimmed milk.
Milk-mix shakes made with water are a lighter option, not a full meal replacement.6 Read how to choose a shake for more.
How long should I stay on a shake diet plan?
The Everyday Plan is 8 weeks. For the Total Plan, how long you stay on it is something to agree with your GP, and the plan page sets out the details.
Then you step down to the Maintenance Plan, which tapers from two meal replacements a day to one over stages of at least three to four weeks.5 Our guide explains how to come off shakes.
Do I need to exercise on a meal replacement plan?
Exercise is not required on every plan. The Active Plan is built to pair with 150 minutes of moderate exercise a week, or 75 minutes of vigorous exercise.5 On the 800 kcal plan and on fasting days on the 5:2 Plan, stick to light exercise only.
Meal replacement bars are a format some people find easier to carry on active days. You can also look at meal replacement bars.
Ready to start with two a day?
The Everyday Plan is two shakes plus a meal you cook. Choose from 11 flavours in single-meal sachets you can mix in one box.
Rated 4.5 from 20,548 reviews. £1.99, or £1.67 a meal in packs. Free standard delivery over £65 and next working day Express before 2:30pm.
Check with your GP before starting the 800 kcal plan.
Sources
- Commission Regulation (EU) 2016/1413 (assimilated), amending Regulation (EU) No 432/2012, Annex, meal replacement for weight control, 2016. legislation.gov.uk/eur/2016/1413/annex, accessed 12 November 2026.
- NICE, Overweight and obesity management, guideline NG246, physical activity and diet, recommendations 1.16.8-1.16.12, 2025. nice.org.uk/guidance/ng246, accessed 12 November 2026.
- Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/1798 (assimilated), Article 4, total diet replacement for weight control, 2017. legislation.gov.uk/eur/2017/1798/article/4, accessed 12 November 2026.
- Astbury NM et al., A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effectiveness of meal replacements for weight loss, Obesity Reviews 2019;20(4):569-587. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30675990, accessed 12 November 2026.
- Shake That Weight, plan pages: Everyday Plan, Active Plan, Total Plan, 5:2 Plan, Maintenance Plan and diet plans, 2026, accessed 12 November 2026.
- Shake That Weight, product pages: Vanilla, Strawberry, Caramel Biscuit, Lemon Cheesecake, bundles, shakes, Shake Selection 30 meals, delivery and reviews, 2026, accessed 18 November 2026.
- NHS England, NHS Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme. england.nhs.uk/diabetes/treatment-care/diabetes-remission, accessed 12 November 2026.
Last updated: 18 November 2026.
Written by the Shake That Weight team and reviewed by Matthew Cooper, Director and Founder. Read our editorial standards.
See our medical and health disclaimer.