Strawberry meal replacement shake in a glass beside a Shake That Weight shaker on a kitchen worktop

Meal Replacements

Do meal replacement shakes work? What the evidence says

Do meal replacement shakes work? Yes, as part of a calorie-controlled diet. In a review of 23 trials, programmes using them led to more weight loss at one year than other diets, and more again with support. They work best with structure, and they are not right for everyone.

Key points

  • Oxford review: 23 trials, 7,884 adults. On average, people on meal-replacement diets lost more weight at one year than those on other diets4.
  • DiRECT (UK, 2018): 46% of the intervention group were in type 2 diabetes remission at 12 months, against 4% of controls. These are group results, and individual results vary1.
  • The NHS programme uses 800-900 kcal soups and shakes for 12 weeks, with 12 months of support7.
  • Without support, results fade: in DiRECT, 26% of people in remission at 2 years were still in remission at 53.

Do meal replacement shakes work for weight loss?

Yes, within a calorie-controlled diet. Meal replacement shakes provide fixed, known energy and nutrients.

In the UK, products that meet specific criteria can carry authorised claims about contributing to weight loss or weight maintenance. The authorised wording states: "Substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss"9.

It also states: "Substituting one of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with a meal replacement contributes to the maintenance of weight after weight loss"9.

For a product to carry these claims, it must meet the UK meal-replacement criteria when made as directed. This includes:

  • 200-250 kcal per meal
  • protein making up 25-50% of energy
  • fat no more than 30% of energy
  • at least 30% of the reference values for vitamins and minerals
  • minimum amounts of sodium and potassium9

The label must also mention fluid intake.

There are two main approaches:

Partial meal replacement
Replacing 1-2 meals a day with shakes, plus eating other food
Total diet replacement
Replacing every meal with shakes or soups, usually under supervision

The evidence below covers both. Our meal replacement shakes are made to these criteria when made as directed: the milk-range flavours with 250ml skimmed milk, and the water-range flavours with 250ml cold water.

Woman taking a strawberry meal replacement shake sachet from her kitchen cupboard

If you want to see what a regulated meal replacement looks like, here are four of ours, with the prep that makes each a full meal: Vanilla and Strawberry with 250ml skimmed milk, Caramel Biscuit and Lemon Cheesecake with 250ml cold water. You can also build your own box.

11 flavours in stock (checked 18 November 2026) · Each meal in its own sachet · Mix and match in one box · £1.99 each or £1.67 a meal in 30 or 42 packs

What does the research actually show?

Yes. Across many trials, programmes that use meal replacements led to more weight loss than other diets, and support added more.

A 2019 review from the University of Oxford looked at 23 randomised controlled trials involving 7,884 adults. It found that, at one year, people on meal-replacement diets lost 1.44kg more on average than those on other diets. With support, the difference was 2.22kg4.

The review excluded total diet replacement and diets under 800 kcal4. It is evidence for replacing some meals, not all of them.

The review called meal replacements "a valid option" for weight loss.

DiRECT and DROPLET tested total diet replacement, with support. Here are the three studies side by side:

StudyYearWhoWhat they ateFollow-upMain findingSource
DiRECT2018149 per group with type 2 diabetes at 49 GP practices in Scotland and TynesideTotal diet replacement 825-853 kcal a day for 3-5 months, then food reintroduction and support12 months46% in remission vs 4%.
Mean change -10.0kg vs -1.0kg
1
DROPLET2018278 adults at 10 Oxfordshire practices810 kcal a day as the sole food for 8 weeks, then reintroduction and support12 months-10.7kg vs -3.1kg with usual care.
45% vs 15% lost 10% or more
5
Oxford review201923 trials, 7,884 adultsMeal-replacement diets (excluded total diet replacement and diets under 800 kcal)12 months-1.44kg more than other diets.
-2.22kg more with support vs other diets with support
4

In DiRECT, 15kg or more was lost by 24% of the intervention group compared with 0% of controls1. In DROPLET, adverse events of moderate or greater severity were reported in 11% of the intervention group and 12% of the usual care group5.

The trial groups were selected. DiRECT took adults aged 20-65 with type 2 diabetes for under 6 years, BMI 27-45, not on insulin1. In both trials, the diet groups had food reintroduction and follow-up support15.

These are group averages from supervised trials, and individual results vary. Some studies were part-funded by a meal replacement company.

Woman reading about meal replacement research at her kitchen table

Why choose Shake That Weight

None of the studies above used Shake That Weight products, so we don't borrow their numbers. What they show is that a structured plan matters. Here is what we offer for one.

  • Made to the UK meal-replacement criteria when made as directed: milk-range flavours with 250ml skimmed milk, water-range with 250ml cold water.
  • 11 flavours, each meal in its own sachet, so you can mix and match in one box.
  • Rated 4.5 out of 5 from 20,548 independently collected store reviews.
  • Trusted by 500,000+ customers since 2012.
  • Diet plans designed by a registered dietitian.
  • A regulated UK food company.
  • £1.67 a meal in 30 or 42 packs, free standard delivery over £65, and next working day Express if ordered before 2:30pm.

Read our reviews

What is the NHS soup and shake diet, and did it work?

The NHS England Path to Remission Programme is a real-world evaluation of total diet replacement for type 2 diabetes. In a 2024 evaluation of 1,740 starters, participants lost an average of 9.4kg, and remission rates were lower than in trials such as DiRECT6.

It is a total diet replacement programme for eligible adults with type 2 diabetes. It provides 800-900 kcal a day as soups and shakes, replacing all meals for 12 weeks, followed by 12 months of support7.

It is available through a GP for people with type 2 diabetes within 6 years and a BMI over 27 (over 25 for Black, Asian and other ethnic groups)7. The programme is delivered in partnership with Diabetes UK.

In the evaluation, 55% completed the programme. Participants lost an average of 9.4kg (8.3% of their starting weight). Individual results vary6.

Among people with two HbA1c (long-term blood sugar) results, 27% were in remission6. The authors noted that remission rates were lower than in trials such as DiRECT.

Shake That Weight is not part of the NHS programme. If you have type 2 diabetes and are thinking about shakes, our guide to shakes for type 2 diabetes covers what to check first.

Can you lose weight with just shakes?

In the trials and the NHS programme, people did lose weight on shakes and soups alone, but only for a set period, with supervision, and then food came back in.

Total diet replacement lasted 8 weeks in DROPLET5 and 12 weeks in the NHS programme7. In DiRECT, it ran for 3-5 months1. It was supervised, and followed by reintroduction to food.

It is not a long-term approach. NICE guidance states these diets need clinical support and are not for long-term use8.

Will I lose weight on 2 shakes and 1 meal a day?

It can help, as long as the rest of the day keeps you within an energy-restricted diet. That is what the authorised claim says: "Substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss"9.

This partial pattern is what the Oxford review studied: meal replacements for some meals, not total diet replacement. Results were better with support4.

The claim only applies within an energy-restricted diet. The meal you cook and the snacks need to fit the plan too.

On the Everyday Plan, that means two meal replacements, one meal you cook (about 400 kcal) and 200 kcal of snacks, for 1,000 kcal a day. It is designed to be followed for 8 weeks. Drink at least 2 litres of fluid a day.

Our meal plan guide shows what a day looks like on each plan.

Person chopping vegetables for a home-cooked meal

Want to keep one normal meal?

The Everyday Plan provides 1,000 kcal a day. It includes two meal replacements alongside one meal you cook each day. It runs for 8 weeks.

Everyday Plan

Want the fastest structure?

The Total Plan (the 800 kcal plan) uses four meal replacements a day, plus 150ml skimmed milk for tea or coffee and 2 litres of fluid. Speak to your GP before starting.

800 kcal plan

Training as well?

The Active Plan provides 1,200 kcal a day. It is made up of two meal replacements, one bigger meal you cook and a 200 kcal snack. It is built to pair with 150 minutes of moderate exercise (or 75 vigorous) a week.

Active Plan

All three plans above were designed by a registered dietitian, and each uses our meal replacements alongside the food the plan sets out.

4.5★ from 20,000+ store reviews Trusted by 500,000+ customers since 2012 Next working day Express delivery if ordered before 2:30pm Free standard delivery over £65

Why do shakes work when other diets don't?

Meal replacements help you keep a calorie deficit by removing some of the decisions.

Each shake provides a fixed portion with known energy. A meal that meets the UK criteria has 200-250 kcal9, so you know the number without weighing or counting.

A product meeting the UK criteria, made as directed, provides at least 30% of the vitamin and mineral reference values per meal, with set protein and fat ranges9.

Fewer food decisions mean fewer chances to eat more than you planned. The structure is what makes it work.

The gap over other diets was bigger with support4. Structure works best with a plan around it.

The shakes do not do the work on their own. The calorie limit does. They make it easier to keep to it.

Here is how our plans work day to day.

How do single-meal sachets make the structure easier?

The fixed portion is already measured, so the structure this section describes is built in.

No scooping or weighing. No working out how much. The measuring is done, so there is one less decision to make.

  • One sachet, one meal. No scooping or weighing.
  • Stays sealed and fresh. Each sachet stays fresh until you open it.
  • Fits in your bag. A meal is always to hand for work or travel. The water-range flavours need only cold water.
  • Mix flavours in one box. The Shake Selection 30 is 9 Vanilla, 9 Banana, 6 Chocolate Mint and 6 Cherry Bakewell. Or build your own mix.

“The strawberry shake and chicken soup are my two favourites, easy to use for work when busy, both taste nice,” K. Whittle · Strawberry Shake

Lemon cheesecake meal replacement shake being poured into a glass

A plan only works if you're happy to drink the shakes. Here is what customers say about the taste: Strawberry is rated 4.8 from 547 independently collected reviews, Vanilla 4.6 from 355, Caramel Biscuit 4.6 from 38, and Lemon Cheesecake 4.8 from 17 (checked 18 November 2026).

“Really nice flavour. Not powdery.”
H. Mander · 10th July 2026 · Vanilla Shake
“Love this shake, my new favourite when I can't get chocolate”
G. Hayter · 20th June 2026 · Caramel Biscuit Shake
“Really tastes like lemon cheesecake.Really nice”
M. Miller · 16th May 2026 · Lemon Cheesecake Shake

Reviews independently collected by Reviews.io. See all reviews

Does the weight stay off afterwards?

Often not fully, especially without support. Keeping weight off is the hard part.

At 5 years, the DiRECT extension group still had a mean loss of 6.1kg3. Group average, and individual results vary.

In DiRECT, 46% of the intervention group were in remission at 12 months, 36% at 24 months2, and 13% of the extension group at 5 years3. Of those in remission at 2 years, about a quarter (26%) still were at 5 years3.

NICE guidance notes that risks of 800-1,200 kcal diets include regain and weight cycling8.

Stepping back up to normal eating gradually helps. The authorised claim for one meal replacement a day states: "Substituting one of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with a meal replacement contributes to the maintenance of weight after weight loss"9.

Good to know

Plan the step-up before you finish. Decide how many meal replacements you will keep, what meals you will add back, and in what order. Having a plan makes the transition steadier.

The Maintenance Plan is built for this stage. If you are coming off the 800 calorie diet, plan the step-up before your last week.

Woman filling a glass of water at her kitchen tap

Who shouldn't use meal replacement shakes?

Shakes are not right for everyone. People who are underweight or have been told to gain weight should not use them, and some groups should check with a GP before any low-calorie plan.

Check first

Talk to your GP before starting an 800-1,200 kcal plan if you:

  • are pregnant or breastfeeding
  • are under 18
  • have a history of eating disorders
  • have type 1 diabetes, or diabetes on insulin or sulfonylureas
  • take other medication that might need adjusting
  • have a BMI under 25 (for very low-calorie plans)

NICE guidance states that 800-1,200 kcal diets should only be used within a multicomponent strategy with long-term specialist support8. They are not designed to be followed long term. NICE recommends no more than 12 weeks, with clinical support8.

NICE also advises against nutritionally unbalanced restrictive diets8.

Our guide to who shakes suit goes through each group in more detail.

Can you lose weight with just meal replacement shakes?
For a short time, under supervision, yes. In supervised trials, total diet replacement led to weight loss at 12 months. DiRECT reported a mean loss of 10.0kg, and DROPLET reported 10.7kg15. Individual results vary. Total diet replacement lasted from 8 weeks to 5 months. It was supervised, and followed by food reintroduction. NICE guidance states these diets are only for short-term use, with specialist support8.
What happens if you drink meal replacement shakes every day?
Used as directed within a plan, each shake replaces a meal with a fixed, known amount of energy and set vitamins and minerals, so the day is easier to keep within a calorie limit. Vanilla provides 212 kcal and Strawberry 210 kcal with 250ml skimmed milk (checked 18 November 2026)10. Drink plenty of fluid. On the Everyday Plan, drink at least 2 litres a day.
Are diet shakes the same as meal replacement shakes?
Not always. To carry the authorised claims, a product must provide 200-250 kcal per meal, with specific levels of protein, fat, vitamins and minerals9. Only meal replacements meeting the legal standard can carry the weight-loss claim. We don't recommend replacing meals with protein shakes, though they can work as a snack. Ours are made to the criteria when made as directed. See meal vs protein shakes.
Can you make meal replacement shakes with water?
Yes, if the shake is made for water. Our Caramel Biscuit and Lemon Cheesecake are made with 250ml cold water and come to 201 kcal. Vanilla and Strawberry are milk-range shakes, but can be made with water instead. When you do, the kcal drop to around 122-125 kcal10 (checked 18 November 2026). This makes them a lighter option, not a meal that meets the UK criteria.
How long can you stay on meal replacement shakes?
It depends on how many meals you replace. The Everyday Plan (two meal replacements plus food) runs for 8 weeks. For the Total Plan (the 800 kcal plan), check with your GP before starting and before carrying on. NICE guidance recommends that 800-1,200 kcal diets last no more than 12 weeks, with clinical support8. If you are still choosing, here is how to choose a shake.

Ready to try a structured plan

The Everyday Plan pairs two of our meal replacements with one meal you cook, over eight weeks. Each shake is £1.67 a meal in packs. Choose from 11 flavours in single-meal sachets. The plans were designed by a registered dietitian. We're rated 4.5 from 20,548 reviews. Free standard delivery over £65, and next working day Express if you order before 2:30pm.

Sources

  1. Lean MEJ et al., Primary care-led weight management for remission of type 2 diabetes (DiRECT): an open-label, cluster-randomised trial. The Lancet, 2018;391:541-551. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29221645, accessed 11 November 2026.
  2. Lean MEJ et al., Durability of a primary care-led weight-management intervention for remission of type 2 diabetes: 2-year results of the DiRECT open-label, cluster-randomised trial. The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, 2019;7(5):344-355. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30852132, accessed 11 November 2026.
  3. Lean ME et al., 5-year follow-up of the randomised Diabetes Remission Clinical Trial (DiRECT) of continued support for weight loss maintenance in the UK: an extension study. The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, 2024;12(4):233-246. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38423026, accessed 11 November 2026.
  4. Astbury NM et al., A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effectiveness of meal replacements for weight loss. Obesity Reviews, 2019;20(4):569-587. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30675990, accessed 11 November 2026.
  5. Astbury NM et al., Doctor Referral of Overweight People to Low Energy total diet replacement Treatment (DROPLET): pragmatic randomised controlled trial. BMJ, 2018;362:k3760. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30257983, accessed 11 November 2026.
  6. Valabhji J et al., Early findings from the NHS Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme: a prospective evaluation of real-world implementation. The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, 2024;12(9):653-663. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39116897, accessed 11 November 2026.
  7. NHS England, NHS Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme. england.nhs.uk/diabetes/treatment-care/diabetes-remission, accessed 11 November 2026.
  8. NICE, Overweight and obesity management, guideline NG246, 2025, recommendations 1.16.7-1.16.12. nice.org.uk/guidance/ng246, accessed 11 November 2026.
  9. Commission Regulation (EU) 2016/1413 (assimilated), amending Regulation (EU) No 432/2012, Annex. legislation.gov.uk, legislation.gov.uk/eur/2016/1413/annex, accessed 11 November 2026.
  10. Shake That Weight, product and plan pages: Vanilla, Strawberry, Caramel Biscuit, Lemon Cheesecake, Reviews, Everyday Plan, Total Plan, Active Plan, Build your shake box, Shake Selection 30 meals and Delivery, 2026, accessed 18 November 2026.

Last updated: 18 November 2026.

Written by the Shake That Weight team and reviewed by Matthew Cooper, Director and Founder. Read our editorial standards.

Medical and health disclaimer