A glass of vanilla meal replacement shake on a kitchen worktop

Meal Replacements

Best meal replacement shakes UK for weight loss: how to choose

There is no single "best" meal replacement shake for weight loss. The best one for you meets the UK meal replacement conditions (200-250 kcal per meal, 25-50% of energy from protein, at least 30% of the vitamin and mineral reference values), tastes good enough to stick with, and costs a price you can sustain. Shake That Weight is one option judged by the same checklist.

Key points

  • UK conditions for the weight-control claim: 200-250 kcal per meal, protein 25-50% of energy, fat no more than 30% of energy, at least 30% of nutrient reference values1
  • A protein shake or a "complete food" is not automatically a regulated meal replacement for weight control1
  • Nutrition depends on how a shake is made: the same powder can be 125 kcal with water and 212 kcal with 250ml skimmed milk (STW vanilla)8.
  • Cost per meal and flavours you will actually drink decide whether you finish the pack

What is the best meal replacement shake for weight loss?

There is no universal best. The best meal replacement shake for weight loss is one that meets the UK conditions for the authorised claim, you enjoy drinking, and you can afford to use regularly.

The UK sets specific composition rules for any shake that can legally claim to help with weight control. The full list is in the next section1.

Check these seven things:

  1. UK meal replacement standard: does the pack or product page state that it meets the UK conditions or carry the authorised weight-loss claim?
  2. Calories per meal: is it within the 200-250 kcal band when prepared as directed?
  3. Protein: does it provide 25-50% of energy from protein, which helps you feel full?
  4. Vitamins and minerals: does it deliver at least 30% of daily reference values?
  5. Sugar and sweeteners: what types of sugar does it contain, and how much?
  6. Taste and mixing: will you actually drink it every day?
  7. Price per meal: can you afford it for the weeks or months you need?

The rest of this guide explains each criterion, shows how popular UK shakes compare in a dated table, and gives you a checklist to screenshot. Our bestselling shakes are made to pass checks 1 to 4 when made as directed.

Pouring a strawberry meal replacement shake from a shaker into a glass

If you'd rather not compare labels, here are three of our most-reviewed flavours plus a newer recipe. Each one comes as a single-meal sachet.

11 flavours in stock (checked 18 November 2026) · Single-meal sachets · Mix and match in one box · £1.99 each or £1.67 a meal in 30 or 42 packs

What should a good meal replacement shake contain?

A good meal replacement shake for weight loss should meet the UK composition conditions that allow the authorised health claims. When a product meets these rules, it can legally state that "substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss"15.

The conditions are:

Nutrient or componentRequirement per meal
Energy200-250 kcal (840-1,046 kJ)
Protein25-50% of total energy
FatNo more than 30% of total energy
Linoleic acidAt least 1g
Vitamins and mineralsAt least 30% of nutrient reference values (Annex XIII of Regulation 1169/2011, except fluoride, chromium, chloride, molybdenum)
SodiumAt least 172.5mg
PotassiumAt least 500mg

These figures come from assimilated Regulation (EU) 2016/1413, which amended the earlier health claims regulation1. You can check them on legislation.gov.uk.

What about total diet replacement? A total diet replacement (TDR) is different. It replaces every meal in the day, delivering 600-1,200 kcal total, and is sold as "total diet replacement for weight control"2.

The NHS Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme uses total diet replacement of 800-900 kcal a day for 12 weeks3. A single meal replacement shake is not a total diet replacement.

STW meal replacement shakes meet the UK meal replacement criteria when made as directed. Our milk-range shakes meet the criteria when made with 250ml skimmed milk, and our water-range shakes when made with water as the pack directs. Always prepare shakes as the label directs, because the nutrition changes with the liquid you use.

Infographic of UK meal replacement shake conditions for weight control

Check first

Before starting any 800-1,200 kcal plan with meal replacements, talk to your GP if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, under 18, have a history of eating disorders, have type 1 diabetes or take insulin or sulfonylureas for type 2 diabetes, take other medication that might need adjusting, or have a BMI under 25 for very low-calorie plans.

Meal replacement shake, protein shake or complete food?

These three types of product are often confused, but they are not the same thing.

TypePurposeTypical caloriesRegulated for weight control?
Meal replacement shakeReplaces a meal for weight control200-250 kcal per mealYes (if it meets UK conditions)
Protein shakeSupplements protein intake, often for trainingVaries by brand and servingNo (not unless it meets the conditions)
Complete foodProvides balanced nutrition, sold as foodVaries by brand and servingNot as standard. Some diet versions meet the conditions and say so

A protein shake is designed to add protein to your diet, usually around training. It is typically lower in calories and is not required to contain the full range of vitamins and minerals a meal replacement must provide. You can read more in our guide to meal shakes vs protein shakes.

Huel's main range is sold as nutritionally complete food. Its Diet Powder is the version aimed at weight loss: 200 kcal and 20g protein per meal6, and its page (checked 10 November 2026) carries the authorised wording for replacing two daily meals. See our guide to Huel for weight loss for more.

Whatever a product calls itself, what the label says tells you whether it meets the UK meal replacement conditions.

Our shakes are sold as meal replacements, not protein shakes. Each sachet is one meal, made to the UK criteria when made as directed. We are a regulated UK food company and have made meal replacement shakes since 2012.

How do popular UK meal replacement shakes compare?

The table below compares popular UK meal replacement shakes on how they are sold and used, plus the core nutrition per meal as prepared to each brand's own instructions. Our own shake is listed first, and the others follow alphabetically.

ProductFormatMix flavours in one box?Flavours availablekcal per meal (as prepared)Protein per mealReview rating on own site
Shake That Weight Vanilla (our shake)Single-meal sachets (34.5g + 250ml skimmed milk)Yes, any flavours in one box1121220.7g4.6/5 from 355 (this flavour). 4.5/5 from 20,548 (store)
Huel Diet Powder34-meal bag, 1 scoop (52g) + 500ml waterNo, one flavour per bag620020gNot shown
Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement BlendBulk powder (500g to 1.53kg), about 2 scoops (51g) + 200ml waterNo, one flavour per pack220618g4.42/5 from 2k (this product). 4.4/5 from 220k+ (store)
SlimFast Simply Vanilla10-meal tin (365g), 36.5g + 250ml skimmed milkNo, one flavour per tin722715gNot shown
The Protein Works Diet Meal Replacement Extreme500g powder, 1.5 scoops (60g) + 350ml waterNo, one flavour per pack1422025g90% from 459 (this product). "Excellent" from 50,000+ (store)

Sources: each brand's UK website, checked 18 November 20266, 7, 8, 9, 10.

How to read this table. Calories and protein are per meal, as prepared to each brand's own instructions. Some brands use water and some use milk, and the Format column shows which. "Mix flavours in one box" means one pack can hold different flavours. Flavour counts are the flavours listed for that product on the brand's UK site. Ratings are as each site shows them, for the product and for the whole store where both are shown.

All five shakes carry the authorised weight-loss wording on their own UK pages1.

Why choose Shake That Weight

The table above compares us with other brands on the same terms. Here is where we make our own case.

  • Meets the UK meal replacement criteria when made as directed
  • 11 flavours in single-meal sachets, mixed in one box
  • 4.5 out of 5 from 20,548 independently collected reviews
  • Trusted by 500,000+ customers since 2012
  • Diet plans designed by a registered dietitian
  • Regulated UK food company
  • £1.67 a meal in 30 or 42 packs, free standard delivery over £65 and next working day Express delivery if ordered before 2:30pm

Read our reviews

Good to know

Why does milk matter? Skimmed milk adds about 87 kcal and 8.7g protein to a shake. The same powder that gives you 125 kcal with water will give you about 212 kcal with 250ml skimmed milk. If a product is below 200 kcal when made with water, it may meet the 200-250 kcal requirement only when made with milk. Check the label for the preparation the brand bases its claims on.

Shopper comparing nutrition labels on meal replacement shakes

How to choose: what to check before you buy

Meeting the UK standard is the baseline. Beyond that, five practical factors decide whether you will stick with a shake.

Protein and fullness

Protein helps you feel full. The UK conditions require protein to provide 25-50% of energy1. A shake with 20g protein in a 210 kcal meal delivers about 38% of energy from protein, which sits comfortably in the middle of the range.

A shake nearer 25% of energy from protein still sits within the range. The shakes in the brand table above give 15g to 25g of protein per meal. If you are hungry soon after a shake, one nearer the top of the range may suit you better.

Sugar and sweeteners

In milk-based shakes, much of the sugar is lactose, the natural sugar in milk. Shake That Weight shakes contain about 23g total sugars when made with 250ml skimmed milk, mostly lactose, with about 5g free sugars (about a teaspoon) per shake8.

Our guide asks are meal replacement shakes healthy, including sugar.

Some brands use artificial sweeteners to keep calories low. If you prefer to avoid certain sweeteners, check the ingredients list on the product page before you buy.

Taste and ease of mixing

You will not finish a pack of shakes you do not like. Taste is personal.

Our six most-reviewed flavours are rated 4.5 to 4.8 out of 5 across 2,715 independently collected product reviews (checked 18 November 2026)8. Strawberry and Chocolate are both rated 4.8, and Café Latte comes in at 4.5. While there is no objective best tasting meal replacement shake, the reviews help you see what other customers say about taste and texture.

Our milk-range shakes are made with 250ml skimmed or unsweetened soya milk, and our water-range shakes with water as directed on the pack. A shaker helps. The shake you will drink every day is the one to pick, and a mixed box lets you try flavours first.

Here is what customers say about the taste:

“Creamy and tasty.”
D. Peters · 19th October 2026 · Strawberry
“Lovely taste not too harsh on the mint flavour”
D. Harrison · 23rd August 2026 · Chocolate Mint
“I absolutely love these shakes, like a perfect iced latte …”
T. Rollinson · 9th September 2026 · Café Latte

Reviews independently collected by Reviews.io. See all reviews

Why do single sachets make shakes easier to stick with?

One sachet is one meal, so there is no measuring and no guesswork. It stays sealed and fresh until you open it. You can toss a few sachets in your bag in the morning, so a meal is always to hand, and because you can mix flavours across a box, you are not locked into one flavour for a fortnight.

  • One sachet = one meal. No measuring, scooping or weighing needed.
  • Stays sealed until you open it. Each sachet stays fresh on its own.
  • Easy to carry. Fits in a bag, so a meal is always to hand when you need it.
  • Mix flavours in one box. The Shake Selection 30 is 9 Vanilla, 9 Banana, 6 Chocolate Mint and 6 Cherry Bakewell, or build your own mix.

“The variety of flavours across the different products is excellent. Easy to prepare the meals.” M., verified buyer

Banana meal replacement shakes 30 meal pack

Price per meal

Compare the cost per meal, not per pack. Divide the pack price by the number of meals, and add the cost of any milk the shake needs.

Shake That Weight meal replacement shakes are £1.99 each when bought individually, or £1.67 per meal in 30 or 42 packs. The pack price is 32p less per meal. A 30-pack lasts about two weeks at two shakes a day.

The 30 and 42 packs include a mixed Shake Selection, so the lower price does not mean one flavour for a fortnight.

Dietary needs

All 11 Shake That Weight shake flavours are vegetarian, and 9 are labelled gluten free. Lemon Cheesecake and Caramel Biscuit are not gluten free8.

Our vegan flavours are Tropical, Cherry Bakewell and Chocolate Hazelnut. For more plant-based choices, see our guide to Vegan options.

If you have coeliac disease, check the label for a gluten-free statement. If you have a milk allergy, look for a pea-protein or soy-protein shake, and check the allergen information carefully.

You can build your own box of flavours to try before committing to a 30-pack.

Strawberry meal replacement shake served in a glass

Want the fastest structure?

The Total Plan is 800 kcal a day from four meal replacements, plus 150ml skimmed milk for tea or coffee and 2 litres of fluid. Check with your GP first.

Total Plan

Want to keep one normal meal?

The Everyday Plan is 1,000 kcal a day: two meal replacements, one meal you cook (about 400 kcal), and 200 kcal of snacks. It is designed to follow for 8 weeks.

Everyday Plan

Training as well?

The Active Plan is 1,200 kcal a day: two meal replacements, one bigger meal you cook, and a 200 kcal snack. Built to pair with 150 minutes of moderate (or 75 vigorous) exercise a week.

Active Plan
4.5★ from 20,000+ store reviews Trusted by 500,000+ customers since 2012 Next working day Express delivery if ordered before 2:30pm Free standard delivery over £65

Do meal replacement shakes help you lose weight?

Yes, when used as part of a calorie-restricted diet. The authorised health claim states that "substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss"15. This wording is backed by evidence and approved by UK regulators.

The most cited trial is DiRECT, published in The Lancet in 2018. It recruited 306 people with type 2 diabetes and analysed 149 per arm. Of the intervention group, 36 people (24%) lost about 2st 5lb (15kg) or more at 12 months4. These are group figures.

The intervention was a total diet replacement of about 825-853 kcal a day for 3-5 months, then food reintroduction, delivered with support through GP practices. It is not the same as using shakes on their own. Individual results vary.

The NHS Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme uses total diet replacement soups and shakes of 800-900 kcal a day for 12 weeks, replacing all normal meals, with support for 12 months3. This is not the same as using two meal replacement shakes a day alongside normal food. The NHS programme is a structured, medically supervised intervention.

Meal replacement shakes take the guesswork out of calorie counting. You know exactly how many calories are in each shake. The Everyday Plan is two meal replacements, one cooked meal of about 400 kcal and 200 kcal of snacks, for 1,000 kcal a day.

You can read more about how shakes work in our other guide.

Woman with a shaker bottle in a kitchen

Your 7-point checklist

Screenshot this list and take it with you when you shop. A good meal replacement shake for weight loss:

  1. Meets the UK standard: does the pack or product page state that it meets the UK meal replacement conditions or carry the authorised weight-loss claim?
  2. Is within 200-250 kcal when prepared as directed (check whether it is made with water or milk)
  3. Protein provides 25-50% of the energy: multiply grams of protein by four, then divide by the kcal.
  4. Lists at least 30% of daily vitamin and mineral values on the label
  5. Tastes good enough that you will drink it every day (read reviews)
  6. Costs a price you can sustain for weeks or months (calculate cost per meal, not per pack)
  7. Fits your dietary needs (gluten-free, vegan, low sugar, whatever matters to you)

Items 1 to 4 are about the rules, and items 5 to 7 are about you. A shake that passes the first four but fails on taste or price is still the wrong shake for you.

Seven-point checklist for choosing a meal replacement shake
What shakes do the NHS use for weight loss?
The NHS Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme uses total diet replacement soups and shakes of 800-900 kcal a day for 12 weeks, replacing all normal meals3. The programme is for some people with type 2 diabetes. It is a total diet replacement, not shakes used alongside normal meals. The programme is medically supervised and includes support for 12 months.
What is the most effective weight-loss shake?
There is no single most effective weight-loss shake. Any shake that meets the UK meal replacement conditions and is used as part of an energy restricted diet contributes to weight loss when it replaces two of your main daily meals. The most effective shake is the one you enjoy enough to stick with. Use the 7-point checklist above to choose.
How many meal replacement shakes should I have a day?
The authorised health claim refers to substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements1. In practice that usually means replacing breakfast and lunch with shakes, plus one cooked meal of about 400 kcal and 200 kcal of snacks. The 800 kcal Total Plan uses four meal replacements a day. Check with your GP before starting the Total Plan. Read more about who shakes suit.
Are there vegan or gluten-free meal replacement shakes?
Yes. All 11 Shake That Weight shake flavours are vegetarian, and 9 are labelled gluten free. Lemon Cheesecake and Caramel Biscuit are not gluten free. Our three vegan flavours are Tropical, Cherry Bakewell and Chocolate Hazelnut8. Check the product page for allergen statements and gluten-free certification before you buy if you have coeliac disease or a severe allergy.
Can I make meal replacement shakes with water instead of milk?
Yes. Our five water-range shakes are made to be used with water and come to 200-204 kcal as directed. Our milk-range shakes are made with 250ml skimmed milk and are 210-212 kcal. When you make a milk-range shake with water instead, it comes to about 125-150 kcal and falls below the 200 kcal minimum, so it gives you less protein and energy8. Check the label to see what preparation the brand bases its nutrition claims on.

Ready to try them?

Choose from 11 flavours in single-meal sachets and mix and match across one box. Rated 4.5 out of 5 from 20,548 reviews. £1.99 each or £1.67 a meal in 30 or 42 packs, with free standard delivery over £65 and next working day Express delivery if ordered before 2:30pm.

Sources

  1. Commission Regulation (EU) 2016/1413 of 24 August 2016 amending Regulation (EU) No 432/2012 (meal replacement for weight control conditions and claim wordings; assimilated UK law), legislation.gov.uk/eur/2016/1413, accessed 10 November 2026
  2. Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/1798 of 2 June 2017 supplementing Regulation (EU) No 609/2013 (total diet replacement for weight control; assimilated UK law), legislation.gov.uk/eur/2017/1798, accessed 10 November 2026
  3. NHS England, NHS Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme, england.nhs.uk, accessed 10 November 2026
  4. Lean MEJ et al., "Primary care-led weight management for remission of type 2 diabetes (DiRECT): an open-label, cluster-randomised trial", The Lancet 2018;391:541-551, pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29221645, accessed 10 November 2026
  5. Commission Regulation (EU) No 432/2012 of 16 May 2012 establishing a list of permitted health claims made on foods (assimilated UK law), as amended, legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/432, accessed 10 November 2026
  6. Huel Ltd, Diet Powder product page and Mix and Match page, uk.huel.com/products/huel-diet-powder, uk.huel.com/mix-and-match, accessed 18 November 2026
  7. Myprotein, Protein Meal Replacement Blend product page, myprotein.com, accessed 18 November 2026
  8. Shake That Weight, product and range pages: Vanilla, Strawberry, Banana 30 meals, Shakes, Chocolate Mint, Café Latte, Shake Selection 30 meals, Build your shake box, Reviews (Reviews.io), Delivery, accessed 18 November 2026
  9. SlimFast UK, Simply Vanilla meal replacement shake mix product page (flavours, nutrition, and its "Buy online" retailer links for the 365g tin), slimfast.co.uk, accessed 18 November 2026
  10. The Protein Works, Diet Meal Replacement Extreme product page, theproteinworks.com, accessed 18 November 2026

Last updated: 18 November 2026.

Written by the Shake That Weight team and reviewed by Matthew Cooper, Director and Founder. Read our editorial standards.

Medical and health disclaimer